Which electronic drum kit should I buy?
The one that fits four answers, in this order.
- Who is playing? Someone finding out whether they like it needs a first kit. Someone taking lessons, or coming back to drums, should look at the kits for a beginner who intends to stay. A drummer moving from an acoustic kit will miss a hi-hat on a stand first: that is the intermediate section.
- What does the home allow? Every kit here is played on headphones. What is left is the tap of sticks and the thump of the kick on the floor; the question about flats says what helps.
- What is the budget? Use the buttons above the table. Add the parts the box leaves out, which the last section lists per kit: above $1,000 it is often a kick pedal and a hi-hat stand.
- Should the kit grow? If yes, the column to read is "Room to grow", and the kits that cannot be added to are named below.
What should I look for in an electronic drum kit?
- Mesh or rubber. Mesh heads give under the stick more like a drum head and are generally quieter to hit. A mesh snare is the first thing the dearer entry kits add.
- The kick. The cheapest kits have a pedal with a sensor and no beater. A kick pad or tower takes a real pedal, which is the motion an acoustic kit asks of your foot, and only a pad takes a double pedal.
- The hi-hat. A pad with a separate pedal on the floor, or a pad that moves on a real hi-hat stand. The second is closer to an acoustic hi-hat and the stand is often not in the box.
- Zones. A pad with two zones tells head from rim, and a three-zone ride has a bell. They change the module’s sound; in a chart game every zone of a pad is the same note.
- Spare inputs. A free trigger input is a second crash or a fourth tom later, for the price of a pad.
- USB MIDI. It is what lets software hear the kit, and every kit below has it but one.
The kits at a glance
The kits are the ones with a Kit setup page on this site, 46 models from ten makers; other brands are missing because we have not read their pages, not because they are worse. Prices were read on November 11, 2026 at Guitar Center, Sweetwater, ProAudioStar, Thomann, Donner’s own store and three smaller shops, and in Roland’s press releases for three kits no shop page gave us, and are shown as ranges because they move. Millenium and Carlsbro are priced in euros and pounds and sit in the range their own number falls in. "Used only" means the maker marks the kit discontinued.
Show kits by budget
| Kit | Level | Price range | Snare and toms | Hi-hat | Kick | Room to grow |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Donner DED-80 | First kit | Under $300 | Mesh snare and toms, 6.5-inch, single zone | Pad and pedal | Pedal only, no pad | No spare input listed |
| Millenium MPS-150 | First kit | Under €300 | Rubber pads | Pad and hi-hat controller | Kick pad and a pedal | No spare input listed |
| Carlsbro CSD25M | First kit | Under £300 | Mesh snare and toms | Pad and control pedal | Pedal only; a mesh kick pad is an option | Options: mesh kick pad, fourth tom, second crash, a hi-hat stand |
| Alesis Nitro Max | First kit | $300 to $500 | Mesh snare and toms | Pad and floor pedal | Kick tower with a pedal, 6-inch pad | Tom 4 and Crash 2 inputs; Alesis sells an expansion kit |
| Simmons Titan 50 | First kit | $300 to $500 | Mesh snare and toms | Pad and controller pedal | 6-inch pad and a pedal; Simmons says single or double pedals fit | Expansion pack: a crash and an 8-inch tom |
| Donner DED-200X | First kit | $300 to $500 | Mesh snare (dual zone) and toms | Pad and pedal | Kick pad and a pedal; Donner says a double pedal fits | Not stated: the second crash it ships with uses the DED-200’s spare input |
| Donner DED-200 | First kit | $300 to $500 | Mesh snare (dual zone) and toms (single zone), 8-inch | Pad and pedal | 6.5-inch rubber pad and a pedal | One spare input, CRASH 2 |
| Yamaha DTX402K | First kit | $300 to $500 | Not stated by Yamaha (7.5-inch pads) | Pad and HH40 pedal | KU100 kick unit: a pedal, no pad | No spare input; the manual names the KP65 kick pad and the HH65 hi-hat pedal as upgrades |
| Roland TD-02K | First kit | $300 to $500 | Not stated by Roland (PD-4 pads) | Pad and FD-1 pedal | KT-1 pedal, no beater | A second crash (OP-TD1C); the snare to a mesh PDX-8; the kick to a KD pad |
| Yamaha DTX432K | First kit | $300 to $500 | Not stated by Yamaha | Pad and HH65 pedal | KP65 pad with a pedal in the box; a twin pedal fits | One more pad through the KP65 |
| Alesis Surge Mesh Special Edition | Beginner who intends to stay | $300 to $500 | Mesh snare and toms | Pad and floor pedal | 8-inch mesh tower and a pedal | Two spare ports for a tom or a crash (the original Surge Mesh’s FAQ) |
| Carlsbro CSD45M | Beginner who intends to stay | £300 to £500 | Mesh snare and toms, two zones | Carlsbro’s page lists both a frame hi-hat stand and a control pedal | 8-inch mesh pad and a pedal | Options: fourth tom, second kick pad |
| Donner DED-200 MAX | Beginner who intends to stay | $500 to $1,000 | 10-inch dual-zone mesh snare; Donner’s pages disagree on the toms | Pad and pedal | 6-inch rubber pad and a pedal | Not stated |
| Yamaha DTX452K | Beginner who intends to stay | $500 to $1,000 | Not stated by Yamaha; a three-zone TP70S snare pad | Pad and HH65 pedal | KP65 pad with a pedal in the box; a twin pedal fits | One more pad through the KP65 |
| Millenium MPS-850 | Beginner who intends to stay | €500 to €1,000 | Mesh snare and four two-zone mesh toms | 12-inch pad on a stand; the stand is included | 8-inch mesh pad and a pedal | None: both inputs carry the fourth tom and second crash it ships with |
| Roland TD-02KV | Beginner who intends to stay | $500 to $1,000 | Mesh snare (PDX-8); toms not stated by Roland (PD-4 pads) | Pad and FD-1 pedal | KT-1 pedal, no beater | A second crash (OP-TD1C); the kick to a KD pad |
| Alesis Nitro Pro | Beginner who intends to stay | $500 to $1,000 | Mesh snare and toms | Pad and floor pedal | 8-inch mesh tower; Alesis says it supports double kick | Tom 4 and Crash 2 inputs |
| Roland TD-07DMK2 | Beginner who intends to stay | $500 to $1,000 | PD-10H snare, three 8-inch PD-8H toms (no rim shots) | CY-5 pad and control pedal | KD-10 pad; the pedal is not included | Crash 2 input free; the mounting rod is in the box |
| Yamaha DTX6K-X | Beginner who intends to stay | $500 to $1,000 | Silicone (TCS) snare, rubber toms | Pad and HH65 pedal | KP65 pad; a double pedal fits | The DTX-PRO module takes up to 14 pads |
| Roland TD-07KV | Beginner who intends to stay | $500 to $1,000 | Mesh snare (8-inch) and toms (6-inch) | Pad and control pedal | KD-10 pad; the pedal is not included | Crash 2 input |
| Roland TD-07KV2 | Beginner who intends to stay | $1,000 to $2,000 | PD-10H snare, 8-inch and 10-inch toms (no rim shots) | CY-5 pad and FD-9 pedal | KD-10 pad; the pedal is not included | None listed: the Crash 2 input carries the second crash it ships with |
| Alesis Nitro Ultimate | Intermediate | $500 to $1,000 | Mesh snare and toms | Pad and controller for a hi-hat stand; the stand is not included | 8-inch pad; a double pedal fits | Tom 4 input |
| Alesis Nitro Ultimate XL | Intermediate | $1,000 to $2,000 | Mesh: 12-inch snare, four 10-inch toms | Pad and controller for a hi-hat stand; the stand is not included | 8-inch tower; a double pedal fits. Alesis’ box list names no kick pedal | None: Alesis says the XL uses every expansion port |
| NUX DM-7X | Intermediate | $1,000 to $2,000 | Remo mesh snare and toms, dual triggering | Pad and control pedal with a half-open step | 6-inch rubber pad and a pedal | Tom 4 input |
| Yamaha DTX6K2-X | Intermediate | $1,000 to $2,000 | Silicone (TCS) snare, rubber toms | RHH135 on a stand; the stand is included | KP90 7.5-inch pad | The DTX-PRO module takes up to 14 pads |
| NUX DM-8 | Intermediate | $1,000 to $2,000 | Remo mesh: 12-inch snare, 10-inch toms | On its own stand; the stand is included | 10-inch mesh pad; a double pedal fits | Two trigger inputs |
| Yamaha DTX6K3-X | Intermediate | $1,000 to $2,000 | Silicone (TCS) snare and toms | RHH135 on a stand; the stand is included | KP90 7.5-inch pad | The DTX-PRO module takes up to 14 pads |
| Alesis Strata Core | Intermediate | $1,000 to $2,000 | Dual-zone mesh: 12-inch snare, 8- and 10-inch toms | 12-inch, three zones, for a hi-hat stand; the stand is not included | 8-inch mesh tower; the pedal is not included | Two spare inputs: a fourth tom and a third cymbal |
| Alesis Strata Club | Intermediate | $1,000 to $2,000 | Dual-zone mesh: 12-inch snare, two 10-inch toms | 12-inch, three zones, for a hi-hat stand; the stand is not included | 8-inch mesh tower; the pedal is not included | The Core module’s two spare inputs; Alesis marks an expansion pack as coming soon |
| Roland TD313 | Intermediate | $1,000 to $2,000 | PDX-12 snare, PD-8H and PD-10H toms | CY-5 pad and FD-9 pedal | KD-10 pad; the pedal is not included | CRASH 2 and AUX/TOM 4 jacks; a port for a digital pad |
| Roland TD316 | Intermediate | $1,000 to $2,000 | PD-12P snare with positional sensing, PD-8H and PD-10H toms | VH-10 on a stand; the stand is not included | KD-10 pad; the pedal is not included | AUX/TOM 4 jack; a port for a digital pad |
| Pearl Mimic Pro (module only) | Advanced | Over $2,000 | A module, not a kit | Not applicable | Not applicable | 16 trigger inputs |
| Pearl e/MERGE | Advanced | Over $2,000 | Pearl’s own pads | Fits a hi-hat stand; whether one is included is not stated | A kick pad, or an 18-inch drum with a pad inside | Three accessory inputs |
| Alesis Strata Prime | Advanced | Over $2,000 | Dual-zone mesh: 14-inch snare, four toms from 8 to 14 inches | 14-inch, for a hi-hat stand; the stand is not included | 20-inch kick; the pedal is not included | Not stated |
| Roland TD513 | Advanced | Over $2,000 | PD-12P snare, PD-8H and PD-10H toms | VH-10 on a stand; the stand is not included | KD-10 pad; the pedal is not included | AUX 1/TOM 4, AUX 2 and AUX 3 jacks; three ports for digital pads |
| Roland TD516 | Advanced | Over $2,000 | PD-140DS digital snare, PD-10P and PD-12P toms | VH-14D digital hi-hat; the stand is not included | KD-12 pad; the pedal is not included | AUX 1/TOM 4, AUX 2 and AUX 3 jacks |
| Roland TD713 | Advanced | Over $2,000 | PD-14DSX digital snare, four 10-inch PDX-100 toms | VH-14D digital hi-hat; the stand is not included | KD-12 pad; the pedal is not included | AUX 1 to AUX 4 jacks |
| Roland TD716 | Advanced | Over $2,000 | PD-14DSX digital snare, two 10-inch and two 12-inch toms | VH-14D digital hi-hat; the stand is not included | KD-18-BK 18-inch kick drum; the pedal is not included | AUX 1 to AUX 4 jacks |
| Roland TD-1K and TD-1KV | First kit | Used only | TD-1KV: mesh snare; toms not stated | Pad and pedal | A pedal, no beater | A second crash (OP-TD1C); the kick to a KT-10 or KD-9 |
| Roland TD-11KV | Beginner who intends to stay | Used only | Mesh snare and two mesh toms | CY-5 pad and FD-8 pedal | KD-9 pad; a double pedal can be used | Crash 2 input |
| Roland TD-17KV2 | Intermediate | Used only | Mesh: 12-inch snare, 8-inch toms | CY-5 pad and FD-9 pedal | KD-10 pad | Crash 2 and AUX jacks |
| Roland TD-17KVX2 | Intermediate | Used only | Mesh: 12-inch snare, 8-inch toms | VH-10 on a stand; the stand is not included | KD-10 pad | AUX jack (Crash 2 carries the second crash) |
| Roland TD-27KV2 | Advanced | Used only | Mesh; a 14-inch digital snare | VH-14D on a stand; the stand is not included | KD-10 pad; single or double pedals | AUX 1 to 3 and Crash 2 jacks |
| Alesis Strike Pro Special Edition | Advanced | Used only | Mesh: 14-inch snare, toms from 8 to 14 inches | A movable hi-hat; whether a stand is included is not stated | A 20-inch kick drum | Not stated |
| Alesis Nitro Mesh | First kit | Price not read | Mesh snare and toms, 8-inch | Pad and floor pedal | Kick tower with a pedal | Tom 4 and Crash 2 inputs |
| Simmons SD600 | First kit | Price not read | Mesh snare and toms, dual zone | Pad and pedal | Mesh kick tower with a pedal in the box | Two inputs; an expansion pack adds a tom and a crash |
The level is ours, by a rule you can argue with. A first kit has a hi-hat on a pedal and a kick that is a pedal or a small pad, at $500 or less. A kit for a beginner who intends to stay adds at least two of a mesh snare, a kick pad for a real pedal and a way to add a pad. Intermediate is a hi-hat on a stand, or a module with room for more pads than the kit ships with, at four figures. Advanced is the rest. The makers’ own words do not help: "professional" is printed on kits in the $1,000 to $2,000 range.
Which kit for a first kit?
Eight pads, a pedal for a hi-hat, and a price that survives the kit ending up under a bed. All of these play every song; what they leave out is the feel of a real pedal under each foot.
- Donner DED-80 (Under $300). Small mesh pads, a pedal for a kick, and a throne, headphones and sticks in the box; nothing can be added to it.
- Millenium MPS-150 (Under €300). The cheapest kit on the list and the only one with rubber pads throughout; nothing can be added to it.
- Carlsbro CSD25M (Under £300). Mesh pads at the lowest price here, with a pedal for a kick; Carlsbro sells the kick pad, a fourth tom and a second crash as options.
- Alesis Nitro Max ($300 to $500). Mesh on every drum, a kick tower you hit with a real beater, and two spare inputs for a fourth tom and a second crash.
- Simmons Titan 50 ($300 to $500). Mesh pads, Bluetooth for audio and MIDI, and a kick pad Simmons says takes a double pedal.
- Donner DED-200X ($300 to $500). The DED-200 with a second crash and a kick Donner calls double-pedal compatible, with a throne, headphones and sticks in the box.
- Donner DED-200 ($300 to $500). Mesh pads, a rubber kick pad you hit with a beater and one spare input for a second crash; sold out at Donner’s own store when we looked.
- Yamaha DTX402K ($300 to $500). Yamaha’s entry kit, with ten training functions in the module; the kick is a pedal with no pad, which the manual says can be swapped for a KP65.
- Roland TD-02K ($300 to $500). Roland’s entry kit; the snare, the kick and a second crash can each be upgraded later, which is the TD-02KV bought in pieces.
- Yamaha DTX432K ($300 to $500). The DTX402K with a real kick pad and pedal in the box, which Yamaha says takes a twin pedal.
- Alesis Nitro Mesh (Price not read). The kit the Nitro Max followed, still on Alesis’ list; one shop we opened marks it discontinued and the others list the Nitro Max in its place.
- Simmons SD600 (Price not read). Dual-zone mesh toms and Bluetooth for audio and MIDI; it is under "current models" in Simmons’ manuals but not in its kit grid.
No kit in this section at this budget.
Which kit for a beginner who intends to stay?
These add what a teacher will ask for within a year: a snare that tells head from rim, a kick you play with a real pedal, and somewhere to plug a second crash.
- Alesis Surge Mesh Special Edition ($300 to $500). Mesh pads and an 8-inch mesh kick tower; the original Surge Mesh has left Alesis’ list and this edition was sold out where we looked.
- Carlsbro CSD45M (£300 to £500). Two-zone mesh pads, a two-zone ride and a mesh kick pad; Carlsbro’s own page disagrees with itself on the hi-hat, so ask the shop.
- Donner DED-200 MAX ($500 to $1,000). A 10-inch snare and 12-inch dual-zone crash and ride; Donner’s own pages give two different sets of toms, so check the listing.
- Yamaha DTX452K ($500 to $1,000). The DTX432K with a snare pad that gives head, open rim and cross stick.
- Millenium MPS-850 (€500 to €1,000). The odd one out: a hi-hat on an included stand, four toms, two crashes and a three-zone ride in this band, and no input left to add anything.
- Roland TD-02KV ($500 to $1,000). The TD-02K with a mesh snare that plays cross stick and a four-post stand; it is the kit WebEDrums is tested on.
- Alesis Nitro Pro ($500 to $1,000). The Nitro Max with an 8-inch mesh kick tower Alesis says supports double kick, and the same two spare inputs.
- Roland TD-07DMK2 ($500 to $1,000). The cheaper of the two TD-07 kits Roland added in October 2026: a KD-10 kick pad for a real pedal, Bluetooth in the module, and a rod waiting for a second crash.
- Yamaha DTX6K-X ($500 to $1,000). The DTX-PRO module, which Yamaha says takes up to 14 pads, under a kit that still has a pedal hi-hat.
- Roland TD-07KV ($500 to $1,000). The earlier TD-07 kit, still on Roland’s list and in limited stock where we looked; the TD-07KV2 has larger pads.
- Roland TD-07KV2 ($1,000 to $2,000). The larger TD-07 kit: 10-inch snare and floor tom, 12-inch crash and ride, a second crash in the box.
No kit in this section at this budget.
Which kit for an intermediate player?
A hi-hat that moves on a stand, bigger pads, more cymbals, or a module with room to grow. Check what is not in the box before comparing prices.
- Alesis Nitro Ultimate ($500 to $1,000). The cheapest kit here with a hi-hat made for a stand, which you buy separately; two crashes in the box.
- Alesis Nitro Ultimate XL ($1,000 to $2,000). Four toms, two 12-inch crashes and a 14-inch ride; nothing left to add, and neither the hi-hat stand nor, by Alesis’ box list, a kick pedal comes with it.
- NUX DM-7X ($1,000 to $2,000). Remo mesh heads, two 12-inch crashes and a three-zone ride, with Bluetooth for audio and MIDI.
- Yamaha DTX6K2-X ($1,000 to $2,000). The DTX6K-X with a hi-hat on a stand that comes in the box, and a larger kick pad.
- NUX DM-8 ($1,000 to $2,000). A hi-hat on an included stand, a 10-inch mesh kick that takes a double pedal, and USB audio with MIDI.
- Yamaha DTX6K3-X ($1,000 to $2,000). The DTX6K2-X with silicone pads on the toms as well as the snare.
- Alesis Strata Core ($1,000 to $2,000). Three-zone cymbals and a hi-hat for a stand. Its notes are not the other Alesis kits’: record every pad in the kit setup, as its kit page explains.
- Alesis Strata Club ($1,000 to $2,000). The Core module with two toms and one crash, for a small space; charts have three toms, so one tom lane goes unplayed until a pad is added.
- Roland TD313 ($1,000 to $2,000). The V31 module under a compact kit: two spare trigger jacks and a port for one of Roland’s digital pads.
- Roland TD316 ($1,000 to $2,000). The same module with a hi-hat on a stand, a snare with positional sensing and two crashes; the hi-hat stand, the snare stand and the kick pedal are yours to add.
No kit in this section at this budget.
Which kit for an advanced player?
This reader is not ours to advise: at this level the choice is about sound engines, digital pads and outputs, which this page does not compare. For playing songs every one of them connects over USB except the Pearl Mimic Pro, and none of them puts more notes on the highway than a first kit.
- Pearl Mimic Pro (module only) (Over $2,000). A sound module for pads you already own. Pearl’s manual lists five-pin MIDI and no USB MIDI, so it needs a USB MIDI interface to reach a computer.
- Pearl e/MERGE (Over $2,000). The dearest kit on the list by a distance, with USB MIDI on the module’s TO PC port.
- Alesis Strata Prime (Over $2,000). Full-size pads, four toms and two 16-inch crashes; like the Core, it needs its pads recorded in the kit setup.
- Roland TD513 (Over $2,000). The way into the V51 module: no digital pads in the box, three ports to add them, two crashes and a three-zone ride.
- Roland TD516 (Over $2,000). The V51 with Roland’s digital snare, hi-hat and ride; kick pedal, snare stand, hi-hat stand and throne are yours to add.
- Roland TD713 (Over $2,000). The V71 module, Roland’s flagship, with four toms; WebEDrums has three tom slots, and the kit page says how to map them.
- Roland TD716 (Over $2,000). The same module with 16-inch crashes and an 18-inch kick drum, at the top of the list.
No kit in this section at this budget.
Which kits can grow with me?
A kit grows in two ways: a pad is added, or a part is swapped for a better one. From the makers’ pages:
- Room for a second crash and a fourth tom: the Alesis Nitro Mesh, Nitro Max and Nitro Pro (Tom 4 and Crash 2 inputs), the Roland TD313 (two jacks), the NUX DM-8 (two inputs), the Alesis Strata Core and Strata Club (a fourth tom and a third cymbal). Simmons sells a pack with a tom and a crash for the Titan 50 and the SD600, and Carlsbro lists a fourth tom and a second crash as options.
- Room for one more pad: a second crash on the Roland TD-02K, TD-02KV, TD-07KV and TD-07DMK2 and the Donner DED-200; a fourth tom on the Alesis Nitro Ultimate, the NUX DM-7X and the Roland TD316; one pad through the kick pad on the Yamaha DTX432K and DTX452K.
- A module that outgrows the kit: Yamaha says the DTX-PRO module of the DTX6 kits takes up to 14 pads, and Roland’s V31, V51 and V71 modules have ports for its digital pads.
- A part you can swap: the kick pedal for a kick pad on the Roland TD-02 kits and the Yamaha DTX402K, the snare for a mesh one on the TD-02K, the hi-hat pedal on the DTX402K. Carlsbro lists a mesh kick pad for the CSD25M.
- Nothing to add: the Millenium MPS-150 and the Donner DED-80 (no input listed), the Millenium MPS-850 and the Alesis Nitro Ultimate XL (every input is used by what ships), the Yamaha DTX402K (no spare jack) and the Roland TD-07KV2 (its Crash 2 input carries the second crash).
The hi-hat is the part to get right the first time. Of the kits with a pad and a floor pedal, only Carlsbro lists a hi-hat stand as an option; the other makers’ kit pages name no way from one to the other. And one upgrade is free on every kit: the USB cable. The software a kit talks to changes more in a year than its module does.
What do owners complain about on each kit?
The part the makers’ pages leave out. Each line is our paraphrase of something reviewers or owners say. A line with no label rests on two or more reviews we read; the others say what they rest on. Under each, what it changes when you play songs, because most of the complaints at the entry level are about the price range rather than the model, and few of them change what lands on the highway. Read on November 11, 2026; the budget buttons above filter these too.
Roland TD-02K and TD-02KV
- The kick is a pedal with no beater: it does not feel like a real pedal, and a double pedal needs a kick pad bought separately. For playing songs: Matters for Expert+ charts, which are written for two kick pedals.
- The module has 16 kits, none of them editable or saveable, and Bluetooth needs an adaptor sold separately. For playing songs: None: WebEDrums reads the notes over USB.
- Small single-zone tom and cymbal pads without rims, and no bell on the ride (the TD-02KV’s mesh snare is the exception). For playing songs: No effect on the highway: every zone of a pad lands on one lane.
- Pads turn on the rack posts unless clamped hard. (one review)
Alesis Nitro Max
- The light rack wobbles and its joints need re-tightening.
- The kick pad is too small for many double pedals. For playing songs: Matters for Expert+ charts, which are written for two kick pedals.
- The toms are single-zone, with one sensor near the rim. For playing songs: No effect on the highway: every zone of a pad lands on one lane.
- Only the few BFD kits in the module sound good. For playing songs: None if the browser plays the drum sounds (Settings, Audio).
Alesis Nitro Mesh
- Single-zone rubber cymbals, no bell on the ride; a hi-hat with open, half and closed only; a small kick target that drops fast double strokes; small 8-inch pads on a rack that gets cramped with a fourth tom. (one review) For playing songs: Only the kick matters for charts, on Expert+.
Alesis Nitro Pro
- The hi-hat is still a pad and a pedal with three positions, and the cymbals are single-zone with no bell on the ride. (one review) For playing songs: No effect on the highway: open and closed hi-hat notes are the same lane. You hear it in the module’s own sounds.
- The module’s display shows numbers, not names. (one review) For playing songs: None: the Alesis preset maps the pads.
Alesis Nitro Ultimate and Ultimate XL
- The hi-hat is made for a stand and the stand is not in the box. For playing songs: A cost to add to the price range.
- The module is hard to read: a three-character display, unchanged from the Nitro Pro. For playing songs: None.
- The cymbals feel flimsy next to the drums, and the ride has no bell. (one review) For playing songs: No effect on the highway: every zone of a pad lands on one lane.
Alesis Surge Mesh
- Dated module sounds, one sample per pad, little change with how hard you hit. For playing songs: None if the browser plays the drum sounds (Settings, Audio).
- Single-zone cymbals and a hi-hat pedal with a limited response. (one review) For playing songs: No effect on the highway: open and closed hi-hat notes are the same lane. You hear it in the module’s own sounds.
Simmons Titan 50
- The hi-hat pedal is close to on or off. For playing songs: No effect on the highway: open and closed hi-hat notes are the same lane. You hear it in the module’s own sounds.
- Single-zone cymbals with little dynamic range. For playing songs: Accents on cymbals may be harder to land.
- The bundled kick pedal is worth replacing. For playing songs: The pad takes a real pedal, so it can be.
- Plastic joints on the rack, and single-zone toms. For playing songs: No effect on the highway: every zone of a pad lands on one lane.
Simmons SD600
- The hi-hat fires as a ride or a crash for some owners using drum software. (owners, no professional review) For playing songs: It would land on the wrong lane: try it before buying, and record every pad in the kit setup.
Yamaha DTX402K, DTX432K and DTX452K
- The DTX402K’s kick is a pedal with no pad. For playing songs: Matters for Expert+ charts, which are written for two kick pedals.
- Small 7.5-inch rubber pads, and single-zone toms. For playing songs: No effect on the highway: every zone of a pad lands on one lane.
Millenium MPS-150
- The rubber pads wear through at the centre.
- Few sounds, and dated ones; single-zone pads with little nuance. (one review) For playing songs: Ghost notes and accents are harder to tell apart.
Millenium MPS-850
- A temperamental hi-hat that opens and closes on its own, and module sounds that are the weak point. (buyers on one shop’s review page) For playing songs: The hi-hat lands on its lane either way; the sounds do not matter if the browser plays them.
Donner DED-80 and DED-200 kits
- DED-80: the pedals are switches, so the hi-hat is open or closed and nothing between, and the pads have a narrow dynamic range. (one review) For playing songs: Open and closed hi-hat are one lane; ghost notes and accents are harder to tell apart.
- DED-200: an awkward, limited module, one cable loom for every pad, and clumsy fast rolls and chokes. (one review)
- DED-200 MAX: no Bluetooth, flat sounds with one sample each, and a weak kick pedal and throne. (one review) For playing songs: None if the browser plays the drum sounds (Settings, Audio).
DED-200X: nothing reliable found.
Alesis Strata Core, Club and Prime
- Strata Core: the module freezing or humming, a kick tower that shifts under a double pedal, and missed hits in fast passages. (buyers on one shop’s review page) For playing songs: A missed hit is a missed note: try fast doubles before buying.
- Strata Prime: a heavy kit in two boxes with a slow rack to build, and a touchscreen that lags. (one review) For playing songs: None.
- Strata Club: some basic hardware is missing, and the cymbal arms are short and stiff. (one review)
Carlsbro CSD25M and CSD45M
Nothing reliable found: shop listings only, no review we could open.
Roland TD-07 kits
- TD-07KV: small pads, an 8-inch snare and 6-inch toms. The TD-07KV2 and TD-07DMK2 have a 10-inch snare and 8-inch toms.
- The ride has no bell, on the TD-07KV and the TD-07KV2; a three-zone ride costs extra and takes the spare input. For playing songs: No effect on the highway: every zone of a pad lands on one lane.
- The module has one mini-jack output and no MIDI socket. For playing songs: None: USB carries the MIDI.
Yamaha DTX6K-X, DTX6K2-X and DTX6K3-X
- The tom pads are single-zone on all three kits. For playing songs: No effect on the highway: every zone of a pad lands on one lane.
- Small pads for the price.
- The DTX6K-X and DTX6K2-X have rubber toms, not the silicone of the snare. For playing songs: Feel only.
NUX DM-7X and DM-8
- DM-8: saving your own kits is awkward, with no empty slots to save into. (one review) For playing songs: None.
DM-7X: nothing reliable found.
Roland TD313 and TD316
We have not collected reviews of these two kits yet.
Roland TD513 and TD516
- TD516: no stands and no kick pedal in the box. For playing songs: A cost to add.
- TD516: it ships with the earlier PD-140DS digital snare, not the PD-14DSX of the 7 Series. For playing songs: None.
TD513: nothing reliable found.
Roland TD713 and TD716
- TD716: the price.
- TD716: no stands or pedal included, and the full sound library needs a paid Roland Cloud subscription. (one review) For playing songs: None for the library: WebEDrums reads the notes.
TD713: nothing reliable found.
Pearl e/MERGE
- Very expensive, and the hi-hat stand and kick pedal are not included. For playing songs: A cost to add.
Pearl Mimic Pro
- The USB port is for a memory stick: no USB MIDI. (the maker’s own support page) For playing songs: It needs a USB MIDI interface on its five-pin MIDI OUT to reach the browser.
- A small sound library, and patchy compatibility with other makers’ pads and hi-hats. (one review) For playing songs: Check your pads against Pearl’s list first.
Roland TD-1K and TD-1KV (used)
- A kick pedal with no beater: little resistance, no double bass. For playing songs: Matters for Expert+ charts, which are written for two kick pedals.
- The module has 15 kits and no editing; the cymbals are tiny, and the TD-1K’s snare has no rim. For playing songs: No effect on the highway: every zone of a pad lands on one lane.
Roland TD-11KV (used)
- Dear for what it offers, with a module that is showing its age.
- The FD-8 hi-hat pedal is the weak point. (one review) For playing songs: A part to test on a used kit.
Roland TD-17KV2 and TD-17KVX2 (used)
- TD-17KV2: the hi-hat is the small CY-5 on a pedal, not on a stand. For playing songs: No effect on the highway: open and closed hi-hat notes are the same lane. You hear it in the module’s own sounds.
- TD-17KVX2: the hi-hat stand and the kick pedal are not in the box, and the KD-10 is tight for a double pedal. For playing songs: Matters for Expert+ charts, which are written for two kick pedals.
Roland TD-27KV2 (used)
- Snare stand, hi-hat stand and kick pedal are not included. For playing songs: A cost to add, new or used.
- The KD-10 kick pad is small for a kit at this price.
- 10-inch toms with a hot spot at the centre, on a rack with little room to grow. (one review)
Alesis Strike Pro Special Edition (used)
- The hi-hat is unreliable out of the box and needs its trigger settings tuned. For playing songs: Missed hi-hat notes until it is tuned.
- Pad sensors crack, mostly on the first version. For playing songs: Hit every pad on a used kit before paying.
- The module can freeze on a corrupt SD card or kit. (the maker’s own support page) For playing songs: It stops sending notes until restarted.
No kit in this section at this budget.
Two kits, one budget
The pairs people ask about most, from the two rows and nothing else.
Roland TD-02KV or Alesis Nitro Max?
Both have a mesh snare. The Nitro Max has mesh toms too, a kick tower you hit with a beater and inputs for a fourth tom and a second crash; Roland does not state the surface of the TD-02KV’s tom pads, its kick is a pedal with no beater that can be swapped for a kick pad later, and it has one spare input, for a second crash. The Nitro Max has Bluetooth built in; on the TD-02KV it is an adaptor sold separately. They sit in different price ranges. The TD-02KV is the kit WebEDrums is tested on, which says something about our testing and nothing about the Nitro Max.
Roland TD-02K or TD-02KV?
Two parts differ in Roland’s lists: the TD-02KV has a PDX-8 mesh snare that plays cross stick where the TD-02K has a PD-4 pad, and a four-post stand where the TD-02K has three posts. The module, toms, cymbals and pedals are the same, and Roland lists the mesh snare as an upgrade for the TD-02K.
Roland TD-02KV or a TD-07 kit?
The TD-07 kits replace the two things reviewers single out on the TD-02: the kick is a KD-10 pad for a real pedal (which you buy), and the module has Bluetooth built in, for audio and for MIDI. The TD-07DMK2 and TD-07KV2 also have a 10-inch snare and 8-inch toms. The TD-02KV keeps its pedal kick and its sixteen fixed kits, at a lower price range.
Roland TD-07 or TD-17?
Roland marks the TD-17KV2 and the TD-17KVX2 as discontinued, so a TD-17 is a used kit now. The kits Roland lists above the TD-07 today are the TD313 and the TD316, on the V31 module: spare trigger jacks, a port for a digital pad and, on the TD316, a hi-hat on a stand. Roland’s pages do not call them the TD-17’s successors, so neither do we.
Alesis Nitro Max or Nitro Pro?
The same layout and the same two spare inputs. Alesis lists a 6-inch kick pad on the Nitro Max and an 8-inch mesh kick tower on the Nitro Pro, which it says supports double kick; a reviewer who had both also found the Pro’s rack sturdier and its toms dual-zone. If double bass is the plan, that is the difference that matters.
Alesis Nitro Max or Donner DED-200?
The same shape of kit in the same price range: mesh snare and toms, a pedal hi-hat, a small kick pad with a beater. The makers’ lists differ in the snare (10-inch on the Nitro Max, 8-inch on the DED-200), the spare inputs (a fourth tom and a second crash, against a second crash only) and Bluetooth, which Alesis lists and Donner’s DED-200 manual does not. The DED-200X ships with the second crash and a throne, headphones and sticks.
Yamaha DTX402K, DTX432K or DTX452K?
One module, three sets of pedals and pads. Yamaha’s manual gives the DTX402K a kick unit that is a pedal with no pad, the DTX432K a KP65 kick pad with a foot pedal and a better hi-hat controller, and the DTX452K the same plus a snare pad with three zones. The manual names the kick pad and the hi-hat controller as upgrades for the DTX402K, so the cheaper kit can become the dearer one.
No pair at this budget.
Do I need an expensive kit to play songs in Clone Hero, YARG or WebEDrums?
No. A drum chart has a kick, a snare, three toms, a hi-hat, a crash and a ride: eight pads, which is what every kit in the table sends except the Roland TD-11KV and the Alesis Strata Club, with two toms (the TD-11KV page says how to leave the third out). WebEDrums has a slot for a second crash and none for a fourth tom. Head, rim, bow, edge and bell of a pad all land on the same lane, so a three-zone ride plays the same chart as a single-zone one, and open and closed hi-hat are one lane too. What the dearer kits buy is feel and the module’s own sound, not more notes.
- Dynamics come from how hard you hit, which every kit reports: accents and ghost notes are judged from velocity.
- Expert+ charts are written for two kick pedals. That needs a kick pad wide enough for a double pedal; the kits whose kick is a pedal with no beater need the kick pad upgrade first.
- The connection is USB MIDI. YARG’s wiki says it supports kits with USB MIDI output directly and lists the Alesis Nitro Mesh, the Nitro Max and the Roland TD-1 as examples; the Clone Hero wiki names the Nitro Mesh and the Roland TD-17 among others and warns that very cheap kits may be poor or may not work at all.
The setup differs per game: the Clone Hero and YARG guides walk through it, and each kit’s setup page has the notes its preset maps in WebEDrums.
Should I buy new or used?
Used is how you buy the kits their makers no longer sell, and several of them have a setup page here because people still own them:
- Roland TD-1K and TD-1KV (first kit when new). Roland’s earlier entry kits: USB MIDI only, a pedal for a kick.
- Roland TD-11KV (beginner who intends to stay when new). Two toms, not three; the kit page says how to leave the third out.
- Roland TD-17KV2 (intermediate when new). The TD-17 module with a pedal hi-hat and one crash.
- Roland TD-17KVX2 (intermediate when new). The TD-17 module with a hi-hat on a stand and two crashes.
- Roland TD-27KV2 (advanced when new). A digital snare, ride and hi-hat; snare stand, hi-hat stand and kick pedal are not in the box.
- Alesis Strike Pro Special Edition (advanced when new). Full-size shells, five toms and three crashes; WebEDrums has slots for three toms and two crashes, and the kit page says how to map the rest.
Used kits have no price range: choose All to see them.
On a used kit, hit every pad and every zone at several strengths before paying, and work both pedals through their travel: the Clone Hero wiki warns that used kits can come with pads or cymbals that no longer trigger properly and that replacements are often expensive. The complaints above name the part to test on each. Bring a laptop: the kit setup in WebEDrums lights each pad as you hit it, which is a five-minute test of the whole kit.
What else do I need?
- A kick pedal where the kit has a kick pad and no pedal: the Roland TD-07 kits, the V-Drums 3, 5 and 7 Series kits, the three Alesis Strata kits, and the used TD-11KV, TD-17 and TD-27 kits. Alesis’ box list for the Nitro Ultimate XL names none either, so ask the shop.
- A hi-hat stand for the Alesis Nitro Ultimate and Ultimate XL and the three Strata kits, the Roland TD316, TD513, TD516, TD713 and TD716, and the used TD-17KVX2 and TD-27KV2. The Millenium MPS-850, the NUX DM-8 and the Yamaha DTX6K2-X and DTX6K3-X come with theirs.
- A snare stand for the Roland TD316, the V-Drums 5 and 7 Series kits and the used TD-27KV2.
- A throne, sticks and headphones. Roland says a throne is not included with the TD-07 and V-Drums 3 kits. We did not compare the other box lists, so read the one for your kit.
- A USB cable that carries data, not a charge-only one, to reach a computer. Roland says the modules of its V-Drums 3, 5 and 7 Series kits do not work with USB 3.0 cables.
Questions
Should I get mesh or rubber pads?
Mesh heads give under the stick more like a drum head and are generally quieter to hit; rubber pads are firmer and cheaper. Most kits on this list have a mesh snare and mesh toms. The Millenium MPS-150 is rubber throughout, and Roland and Yamaha do not state the surface of the tom pads on their entry kits, which the reviews we read describe as rubber.
Is an electronic drum kit quiet enough for a flat?
Headphones remove the drum sounds. They do not remove the tap of sticks on pads or the thump of a pedal on the floor, which is what a neighbour below hears. Roland lists its Noise Eater isolators among the options for the TD-07 and V-Drums 3 kits. A mat under the kit and a visit to a shop to hear a pad struck in a quiet room are worth more than any specification.
Do electronic drum kits work with a computer?
Every kit on this list sends MIDI over a USB cable except the Pearl Mimic Pro module, whose manual lists five-pin MIDI and needs a USB MIDI interface. Over that cable a game or an app sees every hit and how hard it was. Each kit’s setup page on this site says which port, which driver mode and which preset.
Can I upgrade an electronic drum kit later?
In three ways, and the table’s last column says which apply: a spare trigger input takes one more pad, usually a second crash or a fourth tom; some makers sell a better part for the same module, such as a kick pad in place of a kick pedal on the Roland TD-02 and the Yamaha DTX402K; and a few kits use every input they have, so nothing can be added.
Is Alesis, Roland or Yamaha better?
There is no honest brand answer. In each price range the brands trade different things: Alesis gives more pads and mesh for the money, Roland’s and Yamaha’s entry kits have a pedal for a kick and an upgrade path, and the complaints section shows that each has a known weak spot. Pick the range, then compare the rows.
Can I try drumming before I buy a kit?
Yes. WebEDrums plays its demo song with the computer keyboard or by tapping the lanes on a phone, with no kit, no account and no limit on the demo. It is not what sticks feel like, but it tells you in five minutes whether following a drum part is something you enjoy.